Perhaps you’ve heard this story before: Americans want to be happy about retiring. But for most, that happiness is tempered by serious fears and doubts about their ability to afford a comfortable lifestyle all the way through retirement.
The latest confirmation of this comes from today’s release of a new survey from the nonprofit Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies in collaboration with Transamerica Institute, which found fewer than one in four age 50+ workers and retirees are very confident they will be able to maintain a comfortable lifestyle throughout their retirement (17%, 23%, respectively).
“Retirement brings freedom and time for pursuing personal passions. Our research finds that retirees are happy, purposeful, and have a positive view of aging. However, many are financially vulnerable and risk running out of savings. Their cautionary tale underscores the imperative for strengthening our retirement system,” said Catherine Collinson, CEO and president of Transamerica Institute and TCRS.
The new report, “Life in Retirement: Pre-Retiree Expectations and Retiree Realities,” is part of TCRS’ 23rd Annual Retirement Survey, one of the largest and longest-running surveys of its kind. It compares the retirement preparations and expectations of age 50+ workers with the experiences of retirees. The survey examines their visions of aging and retirement, when and how retirement happens, life in retirement, and their finances.
Greatest fears about retirement
“Pre-retirees and retirees dream of travel, spending more time with family and friends, hobbies, and volunteer work. Yet their positive outlook is clouded by financial and health-related fears,” said Collinson.
The greatest retirement fear among age 50+ workers is outliving their savings and investments (45% age 50+ workers, 32% retirees), while the greatest fear among retirees is that Social Security will be reduced or cease to exist in the future (42% age 50+ workers, 39% retirees). Many age 50+ workers and retirees fear declining health that requires long-term care (41%, 35%, respectively) and possible long-term care costs (35%, 28%).
Financial fears are well founded
“Retirees and pre-retirees have limited financial means. Both cohorts are susceptible to the turbulent economy and inflation. A harsh reality is that many lack the resources to cover the cost of a major financial shock. If a market downturn, personal health emergency, or natural disaster strikes, many may find themselves in a dire situation,” Collinson said.
“A harsh reality is that many lack the resources to cover the cost of a major financial shock.”
Catherine Collinson
Retirees have put away $73,000 in total household savings excluding home equity, while age 50+ workers have saved $133,000 in total household retirement accounts (estimated medians). Retirees have an annual household income (HHI) of $58,000, significantly less than age 50+ workers’ HHI of $87,000 (estimated medians).
Regarding their expected primary source of income in retirement, retirees and age 50+ workers most often cite Social Security (54%, 36%, respectively). As a sign of the evolving retirement landscape, almost one in five retirees (19%) expect to primarily rely on income from a company-funded pension plan, compared with just 10% of age 50+ workers. In contrast, 26% of age 50+ workers expect to rely on 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and IRAs, compared with 11% of retirees. A noteworthy 11% of age 50+ workers expect to rely on income from continued work. Just 1% of retirees and age 50+ workers expect to primarily rely on home equity or an inheritance.
Avoiding common mistakes = better outcomes
“Many pre-retirees and retirees are experiencing pitfalls that could be potentially mitigated through improved planning,” Collinson said. Fewer than one in four age 50+ workers and retirees have a financial strategy for retirement in the form of a written plan (23%, 19%, respectively).
The survey findings reveal these common mistakes that could be addressed by engaging in more rigorous planning:
- Being overly optimistic about retirement expectations. Two-thirds of age 50+ workers (66%) expect to retire after age 65 or do not plan to retire. In stark contrast, 58% of retirees actually retired before age 65. The median age retirees retired was 62. Retirees’ experience shows how unforeseen circumstances can derail the best-laid plans. Fifty-six percent of retirees retired sooner than expected, with many of them indicating they did so for personal health and employment-related reasons. Yet only 31% of age 50+ workers have a backup plan for income if forced into retirement sooner than expected.
- Overlooking life expectancy and how it relates to time in retirement. While workers have a vision of when they want to retire, many have not contemplated the duration of their retirement. When asked the age they plan to live, 47% of retirees and 39% of age 50+ workers say they are “not sure,” which is a reasonable answer but not useful for financial planning.
- Claiming Social Security benefits too early. Retirees receiving Social Security benefits began at age 63 (median). Thirty-one percent began at age 62, the earliest age possible for Social Security retirement benefits—albeit at a 20% to 30% reduced benefit depending on their birth year and the age they are eligible for full retirement benefits. Only 4% of retirees waited to receive benefits at age 70, the maximum age that brings the highest possible benefit payments.
- Taking inadequate steps to safeguard health. More than seven in 10 age 50+ workers and retirees are concerned about health in older age (73%, 74%, respectively). However, few age 50+ workers and retirees say they consider long-term health when making lifestyle decisions (18%, 20%, respectively). Health issues can undermine quality of life, and given the cost of care, they can have a negative financial impact, too.
- Failing to plan for long-term care. Many older individuals experience a decline in health. Just 14% of retirees are very confident they will be able to afford long-term care if needed. Almost half of retirees (46%) indicate that they plan to receive care from family and friends, if their health declines and they need help with daily activities and/or nursing care. Thirty-one percent do not have any plans for long-term care.
- Not seeking assistance from a professional financial advisor, if needed. Fewer than four in 10 retirees and age 50+ workers currently use a professional financial advisor (35%, 37%, respectively).
“Many retirees and pre-retirees are financially fragile due to the evolving retirement landscape and the increasing societal expectation that workers self-fund a greater portion of their retirement income without the knowhow or resources needed to succeed,” Collinson said. “Their experience is a call to action for policymakers to modernize our retirement system by paving the way for the successful implementation of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 and addressing persistent structural barriers to retirement security, such as access to workplace retirement plans and financial literacy curriculum in public schools. Policymakers must also strengthen Social Security and Medicare to ensure their sustainability for current and future generations of retirees.”
SEE ALSO:
• One-Third of Older Americans Fear Social Security Insolvency
• Biggs: Social Security Exaggerates Shortfall of Retirement Income Replacement Rate
• Why Only 1 in 10 Americans Maximize Social Security Benefits